Monday Morning Matrix Meme: What Governments Need

It is often suggested that governments exist to fight poverty, deal with crime, and deter foreign enemies. So holy is this dogma that to question it is perceived as utterly incredible. But it is precisely at this juncture that one realizes what gives any government value: the problems it is meant to address. If there is no demand, there is no need for a supply. To sell a supply, a consistent demand has to established.

This is why governments cannot remain peaceful and prosperous long-term, for then their necessity would be questioned. (Is it really necessary to tax everyone so much if we’re not at war?) Poverty, crime, and foreign enemies are problems too lucrative to let go. Two very different 20th century thinkers, Murray Rothbard and Michel Foucault, observed this tension in different spheres of society.

Rothbard noted how important war is to the legitimacy of the state:

War is the great excuse for mobilizing all the energies and resources of the nation, in the name of patriotic rhetoric, under the aegis and dictation of the State apparatus. It is in war that the State really comes into its own: swelling in power, in number, in pride, in absolute dominion over the economy and the society. Society becomes a herd, seeking to kill its alleged enemies, rooting out and suppressing all dissent from the official war effort, happily. (For a New Liberty, 347)

Who is going to protect you from the crazy Muslim terrorists? From Russian nukes? From all other perceived foreign enemies? Answer: the government.

And the government, we should add, is largely run by crony capitalists. So the demand for violence is very real in connection to a private supply.

The aircraft companies that suddenly profited so greatly during WWII, for example, became permanent, highly successful feeders at the government’s trough, where some of them are feasting lavishly even now, the post-2001 military buildup having proved a godsend and boon to their stockholders…The last thing these vultures want, of course, is an abatement of the perceived terrorist threat, and we can count on them to hype any signs of an increase in such threats and, of course, to crowd the trough, happily slurping the taxpayer’s money. (Higgs, Delusions of Power, 64-65)

Foucault, the controversial French historian, observed the same dynamics at play with regard to the police state:

“At the end of the eighteenth century, people dreamed of a society without crime. And then the dream evaporated. Crime was too useful for them to dream of anything as crazy—or ultimately as dangerous—as a society without crime. No crime means no police. What makes the presence and control of the police tolerable for the population, if not fear of the criminal? This institution of the police, which is so recent and so oppressive, is only justified by that fear. If we accept the presence in our midst of these uniformed men, who have the exclusive right to carry arms, who demand our papers, who come and prowl on our doorsteps, how would any of this be possible if there were no criminals? And if there weren’t articles everyday in the newspapers telling us how numerous and dangerous our criminals are?” (Power/Knowledge, 47)

All of this is reason to at least pause before rallying round the rifles of one government army or the next—especially in response to a ‘threat’ of ‘national security.’ You just might find yourself being played by a very old game and by a powerful class just looking to make a buck.

LCI posts articles representing a broad range of views from authors who identify as both Christian and libertarian. Of course, not everyone will agree with every article, and not every article represents an official position from LCI. Please direct any inquiries regarding the specifics of the article to the author. 

Interested in Contributing? 

LCI accepts guest submissions by high-quality writers. If you are interested in submitting a guest post, click here to send us mail.

Did you like Monday Morning Matrix Meme: What Governments Need
You may also like These Posts:

Don't Miss an Article about Christian Libertarianism!
Sign up Today!

Whenever there’s a new article, you’ll get an email once a day! 

*by signing up, you also agree to get weekly updates to our newsletter

The Pandemic Bites

Libertarian Christian Answers to Questions about the Pandemic

Sign up for our new email series, and we’ll  share some bite-sized writings with you that discuss various aspects of the pandemic. We will address economics, science, politics, and ethics in accessible chunks with helpful references to learn more.

You’ll away having learned something new and useful as we continue to work past these difficult times together.*

*by signing up, you also agree to get weekly updates to our newsletter


Never Miss A Story

Get our Weekly recap with the latest news, articles and resources.