Radical Ideology or American Empire? Can Islam Peacefully Coexist with the West?

July 2, 2025
Biblical Anarchy Podcast

In this episode of the Biblical Anarchy Podcast, host Jacob Winograd welcomes a special guest, Kasimir, for a bonus episode that delves deep into the Israel-Palestine conflict from a libertarian perspective. They discuss the historical context of Zionism, the influence of various libertarian thinkers, and the implications of applying libertarian principles to the current geopolitical landscape. The conversation tackles both theological and political dimensions, examining the biases present within both the Christian and libertarian communities regarding Israel. They also debate the justifications for Israel’s recent actions against Iran, contemplating the ethics of preemptive strikes and the legitimacy of state actions in warfare. The episode explores different narratives and seeks to find a consistent application of libertarian ethics in analyzing these complex issues.

Main Points of Discussion

Timestamp	Topic
00:00	Jacob introduces the bonus episode, frames the Israel/Islam debate, and addresses personal bias
06:06	Why Christians and libertarians focus on Israel; Kasimir’s return and ideological background
10:31	Kasimir critiques Scott Horton, Dave Smith, and the misuse of libertarian ethics and history
15:36	Degeneracy debates: libertarian ethics, biting bullets, and how to handle taboo cases
19:00	Voluntaryist solutions to moral decay: Amish examples, guardianship, and covenant communities
23:40	State vs. market: how abolishing government would better protect virtue and cultural order
26:00	Current events: Iran-Israel tensions, preemptive strikes, and libertarian critiques of escalation
30:00	Kasimir’s thesis: Islamism as long-term aggression, not blowback—defining the ideology
34:53	Islamic history: conquest of Christian lands, minority oppression, and expansionism
38:33	Jacob’s rebuttal: distinguishing Islam from Islamism, pluralism, and religious nuance
42:30	King-Crane Commission: post-WWI Arab sentiment, hope in U.S. neutrality, and betrayal
45:53	British colonial policy and Zionism: broken promises, Balfour, and rising ethnic tensions
49:00	Jewish migration: purchasing land, exclusion, and competing narratives on legitimacy
54:00	Libertarian property ethics: homesteading, forestalling, and whether early Zionism was moral
59:56	Can fear justify exclusion? Cultural displacement, immigration ethics, and realism vs. liberty
01:06:45	Debating proportionality: does libertarian theory allow for exclusion based on ideology?
01:13:00	Jewish National Fund, land restrictions, and whether libertarian settlers had state aid
01:20:00	Generalizing vs. individualizing guilt: Jacob pushes back on tribal framings and narratives
01:30:00	Zionism and Christian ethics: balancing historical trauma with faith-based moral clarity
01:42:00	Final reflections: persecution narratives, realism vs. peace, and hope for voluntary order
01:56:00	Closing thoughts, mutual respect, and the challenge of applying libertarianism to global conflict

Additional Resources

Biblical Anarchy Ep. 99 – “Is James Lindsay Twisting Just War Theory to Defend Israel?” (June 4, 2025)
Jacob critiques James Lindsay’s application of Just War Theory to Israel, highlighting inconsistencies and moral blind spots relevant to your discussion with Kasimir.
Full link: https://libertarianchristians.com/episode/ep-99-is-james-lindsay-twisting-just-war-theory-to-defend-israel/
Biblical Anarchy Ep. 98 – “Why the Relationship Between Israel and Christians Matters” (May 29, 2025)
Jacob analyzes Christian Zionism and its geopolitical impacts, exploring how modern Christians relate to Israel—ideal follow-up listening for context on the religious aspects of your discussion.
Full link: https://libertarianchristians.com/episode/ep-98-why-the-relationship-between-israel-and-christians-matters/
Biblical Anarchy Ep. 89 – “What Is Biblical Anarchy? Christian Politics and The Justified Use of Force” (February 12, 2025)
Foundational exploration of biblical anarchy, libertarian ethics, and the moral justification for using force, complementing your ethical analysis with Kasimir.
Full link: https://libertarianchristians.com/episode/ep-89-what-is-biblical-anarchy-christian-politics-and-the-justified-use-of-force/

Browse more Christians for Liberty Network Shows

The Christians for Liberty Network is a project of the Libertarian Christian Institute consisting of shows and hosts offering various perspectives on the intersection of Christianity and libertarianism. Views expressed by hosts and guests do not necessarily reflect the view of the organization, its staff, board members, donors, or any other affiliates (including other hosts or guests on the network). Guest appearances or interviews of any incumbents, officials, or candidates for any political, party, or government office should not be construed as endorsements. The Libertarian Christian Institute is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization and does not endorse any political party or candidate for any political, government, or party office. For information about the Libertarian Christian Institute’s core values, please visit this page.