Ep. 91: Is Anarchy Chaos? Answering Objections to Biblical Anarchy Part 1

March 19, 2025
Biblical Anarchy Podcast

Is Anarchy Chaos? Answering Objections to Biblical Anarchy Part 1

In this episode of the Biblical Anarchy Podcast, host Jacob Winograd takes on a unique challenge—answering AI-generated objections to biblical anarchy and Christian libertarianism in rapid-fire succession. Covering topics such as Romans 13, Old Testament kings, just war theory, and national defense, Jacob critically examines common objections to the idea that Christians can embrace a society free from coercive government. Through theological reasoning and historical examples, he argues that biblical anarchy aligns with Christian principles of justice, proportionality, and voluntary cooperation.

Jacob also explores how central planning and state intervention often exacerbate sin and injustice rather than curbing them. He discusses how biblical teachings, particularly the Mosaic Covenant, demonstrate the failures of earthly governance and foreshadow the necessity of Christ’s ultimate reign. While responding to objections on foreign policy, economics, and cultural issues, Jacob underscores how the principles of voluntaryism, self-defense, and covenant theology provide a consistent framework for Christian libertarians seeking to honor Christ as King in all areas of life.

Main Points of Discussion

Timestamp	Key Topics Discussed
00:00	Jacob reflects on the contrast between his podcast intro’s intense tone and his actual demeanor, sharing a humorous church anecdote.
01:22	Discusses his recent absence due to work, family, and travel obligations, and how he’s “relaunching” the podcast with a fresh perspective.
02:43	Explains the episode format: answering 35 AI-generated objections to Biblical Anarchy in rapid-fire.
04:18	Begins with the first objection: Is anarchy inherently chaotic and unbiblical? Answers by distinguishing biblical order from state-enforced control.
06:24	Didn’t God establish rulers in the Old Testament? Breaks down the distinction between God’s providential and moral will.
07:56	If God uses rulers, how can we reject them? Highlights how God can use unjust rulers for His purposes without endorsing their legitimacy.
08:51	Without government, who enforces moral laws? Challenges the assumption that the state is the only source of justice, referencing 1 Samuel 8.
10:12	Did early Christians submit to Rome without resistance? Discusses the biblical right to resist unjust authority while acknowledging strategic nonresistance.
12:03	Transitions into foreign policy objections and encourages listeners to support the Libertarian Christian Institute (LCI).
13:41	Without a government and military, how would society defend itself? Explains how centralized military power is not a guarantee of security, citing historical failures.
16:27	Doesn’t the Bible support just war? Affirms just war principles but critiques how governments rarely exhaust peaceful options.
19:25	Didn’t God command wars in the Old Testament? Explains covenant theology and why Mosaic-era warfare does not justify modern statism.
21:22	Wouldn’t a stateless society just get conquered? Argues that centralized national defense is not a safeguard against invasion, referencing historical examples.
23:09	How would a stateless society prevent terrorism? Discusses how U.S. foreign policy and empire-building contribute to the problem of terrorism.
26:19	Does pacifism make Christians weak? Should Christians ever take up arms? Clarifies that he is not a pacifist but upholds proportionality and the non-aggression principle.
29:41	Does Proverbs 8 justify strong rulers? Analyzes the passage, explaining that wisdom and justice do not necessitate statism.
35:05	Explains how the Mosaic Covenant highlights humanity’s need for Christ and why government-driven law enforcement fails to create a moral society.
38:35	Wraps up with reflections on the episode’s themes and teases part two, which will continue addressing objections related to economics, law, justice, and Christian nationalism.

Additional Resources

What is Biblical Anarchy? https://libertarianchristians.com/episode/ep-89-what-is-biblical-anarchy-christian-politics-and-the-justified-use-of-force/
Conquest of Canaan and the Mosaic Covenant: https://libertarianchristians.com/episode/does-the-conquest-of-canaan-conflict-with-anarchism/

Browse more Christians for Liberty Network Shows

The Christians for Liberty Network is a project of the Libertarian Christian Institute consisting of shows and hosts offering various perspectives on the intersection of Christianity and libertarianism. Views expressed by hosts and guests do not necessarily reflect the view of the organization, its staff, board members, donors, or any other affiliates (including other hosts or guests on the network). Guest appearances or interviews of any incumbents, officials, or candidates for any political, party, or government office should not be construed as endorsements. The Libertarian Christian Institute is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization and does not endorse any political party or candidate for any political, government, or party office. For information about the Libertarian Christian Institute’s core values, please visit this page.